← Return to feed

What Actually Happens When We Give and Receive Feedback Well

Assisted by AI
What Actually Happens When We Give and Receive Feedback Well

I recently had the opportunity to participate in a workshop where several of the activities focused on improving how we give and receive feedback.

The approach we practiced follows a simple three-part structure:

  1. Start with "I appreciate..." and share something genuine that you value about the person or their work.
  2. Follow with "Have you considered..." to offer constructive feedback or criticism.
  3. Close with the receiver simply saying, "Thank you."

I have known this technique for a while and typically try to apply it. At the same time, I often hear people poke fun at this formula. You have probably heard the comments or maybe even thought them yourself: "As soon as I hear someone start with 'I appreciate,' I already know what's coming. Just skip to the criticism, because I just want to know what's wrong."

I completely understand how following a script like this can feel superficial on the surface. However, my own experience and the insightful reminders from this workshop reinforced just how much wisdom is built into this pattern. When both the giver and the receiver open up to why the structure exists, it completely changes the exchange.

The Value for the Giver: Resetting Your Heart and Mind

It is easy to assume that starting with "I appreciate" is just a polite cushion to soften the blow for the other person. In reality, much of its value is actually for the giver.

As a giver of feedback, taking a moment to pause and reflect on what you genuinely appreciate about a person and the value you see them bringing shifts your mind into a much kinder, more empathetic state.

When you reflect on that appreciation and speak it out loud, it naturally changes how you deliver the "Have you considered..." that follows. It allows your heart to rest and releases the tension you might have carried into the conversation if you had launched straight into the criticism from the start. There is a very real mental shift that happens when you lead with gratitude, and its importance cannot be understated.

The Value for the Receiver: Strength Where We Doubt Ourselves

As a receiver, I used to feel the exact same impatience: let's just jump straight to the criticism.

Over time, though, I have realized that both parts matter, and if anything, the "I appreciate" part might be even more important.

Left to my own thoughts, I can be overly critical of myself, often wondering whether certain things I am doing are adequate. Hearing what someone else genuinely appreciates helps me learn more about myself and how others actually see me. Time and again, I have found that the exact area where I think I need improvement is actually something others see me doing well.

Hearing that appreciation tells me that I am making progress and shows me where to lean in even more. It provides genuine strength and encouragement.

Tuning the Constructive Feedback and the Power of "Thank You"

Starting from that place of encouragement also helps me tune in to the "Have you considered..." portion of the conversation. More often than not, the constructive feedback often directly relates to, or builds upon, the very strength that was just highlighted.

Even so, criticism can still be hard to hear. Our natural instinct is to immediately respond, explain our reasoning, or defend ourselves.

As the receiver, remembering to simply say "Thank you" interrupts that defensive reflex. It gives you permission to just take the feedback in, accept it, and process it so you can think clearly about what actionable items to take away.

Just as importantly, saying "Thank you" helps the giver. Concluding a piece of constructive feedback in a comfortable way is surprisingly difficult; without a clear endpoint, the giver can easily feel awkward or feel like they need to keep talking and over-explaining. Receiving a simple, sincere "Thank you" brings the moment to a gracious close for both people.

Taking It Forward: Asking Often and Meeting People Where They Are

My biggest takeaway from the recent workshop is that healthy feedback is a two-way habit of actively giving and receiving:

  • As a receiver: Ask for feedback often, rather than waiting for formal moments.
  • As a giver: Look for everyday ways to offer feedback or suggest giving it, by first understanding how the other person prefers to receive it.

Not everyone processes feedback the same way. For some, hearing it right in the moment works best. For others, a thoughtful DM that gives them space to read and digest privately is much more helpful, or a quiet face-to-face conversation later on. Taking the time to honor how someone prefers to receive feedback, and pairing it with genuine appreciation and a simple "Thank you", turns an uncomfortable routine into something that builds everyone up.

SUBSCRIPTION // SAVE STATE

The Bi-Weekly Save State

Prefer not to check back manually? Get a low-frequency email digest delivered every other week—strictly if new essays, notes, or web apps have been added. Zero spam, and unsubscribe anytime with one click.